A Federal Court ruled that works that are entirely created by artificial intelligence (“AI”) systems cannot receive a copyright under United States law. Contrary to how this decision has been reported in news summaries, the case was decided on a relatively narrow issue, and kept the door open for future decisions to expand on this new area of the law.

The plaintiff used an AI system called the “Creativity Machine” to generate a piece of visual art called “A Recent Entrance to Paradise” (reproduced below):

The plaintiff claimed that the work had been “autonomously created by a computer algorithm running on a machine,” and attempted to register the work with the Copyright Office.  The Copyright Office denied the application on the ground that copyright law only extends to works created by human beings.

Continue Reading 100% AI-Generated Works Cannot Receive A Copyright (But Works Created Jointly By Humans And AI May Be Copyrightable)